Why does evil exist?

So I had to write a paper for my current Theology class about the problem of evil. This is an explanation as to why evil exists in a world created by a perfect God. My husband enjoyed this little essay, while my mother said it went over her head, so I wasn’t planning to post it. But then I thought what the heck, perhaps someone will enjoy it!

<><  Summer

     The presence of evil in the world has raised many questions among both believers and non-believers. Being able to understand and explain this issue is crucial to a healthy understanding and relationship with God, and sometimes necessary in order to convert non-believers.

According to Elwell (413), “Theists and atheists alike have perceived the problem of evil to be a problem about the internal consistency of the following three propositions: “God is all loving,” “God is all-powerful,” and “Evil exists in a world created by such a God.”” With the problem of evil several questions are raised, such as “Why is God allowing this to happen to me?” and “How can I worship a God that does not remove evil from my life?” Also raised are the questions of moral and natural evil.

We see the first example of moral evil when we look at the fall of man at the Garden of Eden (Genesis 3:1-24). The “moral evil” was the act to disobey God, and the natural evil in this instance was the suffering and consequences of sin; including guilt, a breach in man’s relationship with God, and death. We also see hell as a place that contains nothing but moral and natural evil, while heaven contains only moral goodness and natural blessedness (Elwell, 412).

An explanation to answer why moral and natural evil exists is called a Theodicy. Gottfried Leibniz’s Theodicy explains this problem of evil by stating that in order for God to create the best world possible both moral good and evil, and physical good and evil were necessary. This view describes sin as necessary to man’s existence. While Leibniz does not contradict himself within his system, it “minimizes the role of man’s free will and reduces the significance of sin.” (Towns, 514)

The “soul-building” theodicy states that God’s intent on creating man was to create a being in need of moral development so that man could prepare for the kingdom of God. While this system is internally consistent, the flaw I see is that God could have created man already prepared to build the Kingdom of God.

“The free will defense” is a theodicy which points out that human’s abuse of free will is responsible for evil, rather than God. Many people will ask, “why did God give humans free will?” and this theory explains that it was necessary for God to give us free will or we would be no less than robots, and also shows that God is still good because He gave us the ability and knowledge to avoid sin (Genesis 2:17). This system is internally consistent, and argues that God had the choice to either remove evil or make humans free.

Many atheists and non-believers have used the idea that religion contradicts itself in order to disprove it. For this reason, it is necessary to create a theory that is internally consistent. According to Elwell (414), “the crucial question is not whether a theological position contradicts another theistic system or even whether it contradicts the atheist’s views, but whether it contradicts itself.”

I personally agree with “the free will defense” for an explanation of evil’s existence. This view is internally consistent because it proves that God is still good by choosing what was best for mankind when He was given the option to exterminate evil or create mindless robots. It holds the view of an omnipotent God who does what is logical and good, and shows how God is not responsible for the present evil.

I have met people in the past who were angry with God after struggling with evil first hand and they let it pull them away from God, but I have also seen people who have used the experience to be drawn closer to God. When I struggle with evil I have to remind myself, “what is faith if we only have it when things are going well?” (James 1:2-4, Romans 12:12) I believe God chose to allow evil because it was better than creating us without free will, but still if we let God He will use our trials to help us grow.

Whether or not someone is attacking God rather than a theological system by asking questions and pointing out contradictions is determined by their motive. Are they trying to disprove God’s existence, to put down someone else’s beliefs, or bring doubt into someone’s mind about God? Or are they trying to make sense of a theological issue in order to improve their own, and other peoples understanding of these concepts?

The problem of evil in the world will continue to be debated among believers and non-believers. It is necessary that we have a biblically and theologically consistent understanding in order to support our views when questions arise.

Word count: # 800



Towns, Elmer. Theology For Today. Mason: Cengage Learning, 2008. 514. Print.

Elwell, Walter. Evangelical Dictionary of Theology. second. Grand Rapids: Baker Book House Company, 2001. 412,413, 414. Print.


4 thoughts on “Why does evil exist?

  1. What I have come to see is that man chose the knowledge of good and evil, I.e. , right and wrong over
    relationship where he and his wife walked with the Lord in the Garden. From that time until Jesus said, “it is finished”, mankind lived under the curse of constantly being reminded, especially with the giving of the law,which was given so that sin would increase, Romans 5:20, of his shortcomings. Jesus came to restore our severed relationship with God and hence we no longer live by right and wrong but by relationship. And, because Jesus was the sinless lamb of God who Takes Away the sin of the world, we are no longer sinners saved by grace because He took away our sin but have become the righteous of God in Christ Jesus, 2 Corinthians 5:21. When Jesus died, He died once and for all to sin as did we when we were baptized and died to sin because he/she who has died is freed from sin Romans 6:6,7. That is not to say that we won’t ever fall , but if we do, we have an advocate with the Father . We now live, yet not us, but Christ that lives in us. Therefore, we fix our eyes on Jesus, the author and finisher of our faith and no longer on short comings we may experience.

    • Well said. I liked that you pointed out “that man chose the knowledge of good and evil, I.e. , right and wrong over
      relationship where he and his wife walked with the Lord in the Garden.” A lot of people spend quite a bit of time angry at God for misfortunes. I have been there… Fortunately I have always had a close enough relationship with God that I have never been angry with Him, but I have found myself asking why and becoming doubtful at his sovereignty. What we tend to forget as humans is that everytime we choose sin, we contribute to the natural evil in the world we live in.

      If you look at it as cause and effect I think it makes sense. For every action there is a reaction, and the reaction to sin is the evil we experience on a day to day basis.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s